Home / CRAB Park Warriors: Decriminalization Was Set Up to Fail

CRAB Park Warriors: Decriminalization Was Set Up to Fail

By Latoya Farrell and CRAB (Ayx) Park Community Warriors 

The frontline battle in drug policy has been going on for decades and intersects with many areas of society: homelessness, public and individual health, criminalization, policing, surveillance, and employment, to name a few.  

This installment of the CRAB Park Warrior series was written in collaboration with the Warriors and is grounded in their lived experience. Together, we follow the journey towards, and the abrupt abandonment of, decriminalization.  

Despite the devastating impacts of the toxic drug crisis, widespread public support, and countless community-led efforts to save lives, the provincial government’s commitment never matched its rhetoric — decriminalization was set up to fail from the start.   

“Every person lost to the toxic drug supply is someone’s child, sibling, parent, friend, and neighbour. The choice to end decriminalization without implementing safer supply, real supports, or promised programs is not neutral policy tinkering; it is a decision that will predictably cost lives — and taxpayer dollars.” — CRAB Park & Ayx Community Bus 

They Weren’t Just Numbers 

On August 31, 2026, it was Overdose Awareness Day — the 11th since the crisis was declared a public health emergency. I joined the Warriors standing on the steps in Robson Square. We held signs and heard speeches of anger, loss, redemption, and hope. Purple balloons were popped, representing every time someone died from an overdose. We watched as people drew chalk outlines of bodies on the ground. It was jarring, but powerful.  

“Overdoses do not care what nationality you are, what your gender is, how old or young you might be. Overdoses simply do not discriminate in any way. I’m willing to bet that there’s hardly a family in the world that hasn’t been affected in some way or another by this epidemic! Or is this genocide? This issue has been devastating my whole world before I even knew much about it at all… I began learning the realities — not only about drugs or how to save lives — but the cold hard truth is that this is just another form of poverty-pimping.1 — Kay 

As I took it all in, I couldn’t help but reflect on the people I’d lost: my dear friend who gave the best hugs and always knew the coolest places to eat; a hockey star; a sweet doorman who always had a big smile; and a generous family friend who helped me when my mom passed away. They came from all walks of life, each with their own unique story. They weren’t just numbers; they were people who meant something. 

A Spectrum of Drug Users 

People from all cross-sections of society start using drugs for a variety of reasons — maybe it started recreationally, maybe it was prescribed for pain management, or maybe it was to mask the impacts of trauma. I’ve known a wide range of people who use drugs and struggle with addiction like lawyers, teachers, paramedics, and veterans.   

“There are so many people out there that are closet users. You never know who is and is not using—who is a functional addict and who is not a functional addict. I managed to hold down a job for two years while I was homeless and living under a bridge and using.” – Kirs

The stigma of drug use can be debilitating, destabilizing, and destructive, forcing people to use alone for fear of reaching out for help.  

“I am not partying, I am self-medicating. When I have my medicine, I am able to deal with life. When I don’t have it, I get sick. You don’t start doing opiates just for fun, you do them because you’ve got pain that you aren’t able to get help for. It’s really hard to explain that to people. When I have a stable supply, I’m stable. But just being down here in the DTES, you’re criminalized. I don’t have a criminal record because I’m not a criminal.  I do what I can to help people. I care for my community, but that doesn’t matter to people— they hear you do drugs and they immediately see you as a junkie. A bad person that you can’t trust with a needle hanging out of your arm. I don’t use needles; I’m a smoker, not a poker. But they keep shutting down safe inhalation sites, so we have nowhere to go anymore. We still keep each other safe because we know we haven’t got a prayer if we don’t stick together. — Jenni 

Jenni stands at a podium on the Vancouver Art Gallery stairs on International Overdose Awareness Day
Jenni stands at a podium on the Vancouver Art Gallery stairs on International Overdose Awareness Day

Political or social opposition to decriminalization and safe supply is often grounded in the visible impacts of drug use. The Downtown Eastside (DTES) has become a lightning rod for critics of decriminalization. In my experience working with the Warriors, these criticisms are an unfair depiction of the community, and a reductive characterization of a complicated and nuanced issue. 

“The people on the DTES are not the only people using drugs. I know a lot of high-end clientele. I know people who have had multiple interesting careers. I don’t think there is a single family in this country who has not be touched by drugs in some way. There are people in this subculture and that needs to be recognized, there is a spectrum of users. People need to realize it’s not just lower income, poverty stricken, DTES-ers who do drugs.”  — David 

CRAB Park Tent City and Overdose Prevention

While federal, provincial, and municipal governments played drug policy politics, the Warriors rolled up their sleeves and provided care to their community.  

Between 2021 and 2023, CRAB Park Tent City ran a successful peer witnessing program (effectively an overdose prevention program) funded by Vancouver Coastal Health (VCH). Peer witnesses were provided with Naloxone kits, harm reduction supplies, and drug testing kits to distribute among residents.

“During those three and half years, CRAB Park tent city tragically lost two residents to overdoses. There were times when there were as many as 120 residents sheltering in the park! I believe that number would have been higher if not for the CRAB Park OPS program led by peer support workers.” – Fiona 

The daytime sheltering permitted at CRAB Park supported healthcare access for residents. Pharmacists were able to locate their clients in the park, bring them prescribed safe supply medications, like methadone, and answer questions about medical care. 

“I’ve lost count how many lives I’ve saved. I’ve had to administer NARCAN and done CPR. I was a supervisor for two weeks and cooked for the camp. We got so many thank you letters from the woman whose husband we saved at the fieldhouse. One of my friends from Atira helped me with that. I had to assist the paramedics because they only had two of them and they didn’t have enough hands to do what needed to be done.” — Kirs 

Peer witnesses had access to more than 20 interactive courses — known in the DTES as VCH’s “Street Degree” —which covered advanced overdose response, managing medical emergencies and more. To date, thirteen members of the Warriors and Ayx Community Peer Support Workers have graduated. They apply their lived and living experience to fill gaps in service provision in the DTES. They don’t do it for recognition, but to help their community and prevent more lossses to the toxic drug crisis; it gives them a sense of purpose. 

“The people down here need to have a purpose just like everyone else in this world. If someone could help them find a purpose, I know it would change lives. People down here want to be able to help. There are hundreds of positions that could be filled with peer support workers. Get them working and then work on the other stuff. I think it would change a lot of opinions about people on the DTES – which needs to change.” — David 

A Project Promised, but Never Delivered 

In October 2021, the provincial government applied to Health Canada for an exemption to the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act to decriminalize personal possession of illicit drugs in BC. The request was framed as part of a comprehensive response to the unprecedented numbers of drug poisoning deaths. 

On January 31, 2023, the provincial government launched its decriminalization pilot project, which allowed adults 18 and older to possess up to 2.5 grams of specified drugs without the fear of being arrested. While the temporary exemption project fell short of the true decriminalization advocates were calling for, it was a step in the right direction. At the time, decriminalization received widespread support from the public, as well as health and law enforcement leaders. 

So, what changed? Supporters of decriminalization and safe supply often cite the lack of political will as its downfall. For them, the government’s poor resource allocation, inadequate funding, mixed messaging leading to public confusion, and failure to scale up services to meet demand, ultimately undermined the very goals of the project.  

A Midway Shift Toward Recriminalization 

In early 2024, BCCLA endorsed the Canadian Drug Policy Coalition’s “To End a Crisis: A Vision for Drug Policy in BC,” which provided a clear path forward to address the toxic drug crisis informed by peer-led community organizations and people who use drugs across BC. But by April 2024, less than halfway through the decriminalization pilot, the provincial and federal governments amended the pilot project by reintroducing a total ban on drug use in BC with three narrow exceptions for: 

  1. Private residences 
  1. Designated health clinics (overdose prevention sites and drug-checking sites) 
  1. People sheltering outside in accordance with all laws and bylaws. 

This effectively turned BC’s drug decriminalization project on its head, driving drug use back into the shadows and establishing a presumption of illegality.  

“A positive thing about decriminalization was that it made it possible for people to use amongst each other instead of alone. My concern is that overdose deaths will go up now.” — Ryan 

With the Province’s weakening support, municipalities followed suit, passing bylaws, including more restrictive daytime sheltering bylaws, that reduced where people could use drugs while sheltering outside and effectively banning drug use in most spaces.  

Lifesaving overdose prevention sites, which BC’s application listed as “essential evidence-based supports and services,” were shut down by the provincial government and municipalities, creating more barriers to accessing the harm reduction services decriminalization required to succeed. These decisions were made despite there being zero drug overdose deaths inside any official supervised consumption or overdose prevention sites across Canada and research finding a reduced risk of death for people who regularly use these services. 

“It didn’t work because they didn’t want it to work. How are they quantifying it not working? With those safe use sites, it worked! Nobody died in one of those sites. That means it worked!” — Jenni 

The End of Decriminalization  

On January 14, 2026, Provincial officials announced that BC would not renew or extend the decriminalization project. This meant simple possession of drugs would be recriminalized, because, according to them, the project failed.  

“The government intentionally let the decriminalization project fail. They were supposed to decriminalize drugs, increase access to mental health services, and provide addiction recovery beds. They didn’t do all those things. They didn’t come close to meeting the demand.” — Ryan 

While unregulated drug deaths steadily decreased between 2023-2026,3 the data is inconclusive as to what impact, if any, decriminalization had on drug-related hospitalizations and deaths relative to other Canadian provinces.4  

“I feel like the entire decriminalization project was a bait and switch. They got us accustomed to using in public…So, we were safer because we didn’t have to hide. It was a really simple idea, and it was working. But then they changed things. It got confusing; we were getting mixed messages. Before we knew it, they ended it!” — Jenni 

The Warriors Defend Decriminalization and Safe Supply 

On February 3, 2026, in response to the end of decriminalization, the Warriors again spoke truth to power in an open letter on behalf of people who use drugs, their families, and communities across BC. The Warriors called on former Premier Eby, the Health Minister, the Chief Coroner, and others to: 

  • Reverse the decision to end the decriminalization pilot.  
  • Maintain and improve health‑based decriminalization for small personal use amounts, with clear provincial guidance against punitive policing of possession under threshold amounts. 
  • Rapidly scale safe, regulated supply. Expand low barrier safe supply programs in every health authority, targeting the substances present in the illicit market, and publicly commit to measurable coverage targets. 
  • Fund treatment, housing, and mental health support at the scale of the crisis.  
  • Create surge capacity in detox and long-term treatment, expand supportive housing for people with concurrent disorders, and ensure that leaving hospital or jail never means being discharged back into homelessness and toxic drugs.  
  • Fireproof drug policy from FIFA‑style political cycles.  
  • Adopt a human‑rights‑based framework that explicitly prohibits displacement, ticketing, or criminalization of unhoused and drug using people for the sake of “beautification” or event optics. 
  • Report transparently. Publish regular, disaggregated statistics on overdose events versus unregulated‑drug toxicity deaths; possession‑related arrests and seizures before, during, and after decriminalization; and crime trends in key urban centers, to prevent misuse of crime narratives to justify harmful policies. 

To date, the Warriors have not received a response. 

“If people had access to safe supply and to proper harm reduction supplies, a lot more people that we don’t know are using, and don’t feel comfortable with everybody knowing, would be safe. Now, if these people don’t have a way to use safely, we are going to find more of them dying. And that is bunk!” — Kirs 

Finding Acceptance and Purpose in Community Care 

Since the City of Vancouver closed CRAB Park Tent City in November 2024, the Warriors have continued to advocate for law and policy reform, while providing services and care to members of their community. Whether it is daytime sheltering, housing rights, drug policy, access to services, or anything else that comes their way, the Warriors are ready to raise their collective voice to advocate for their community. 

“I suppose they’ll always write us off just as easily in death as they are doing in life. When someone coined the phrase “ignorance is bliss” they sure nailed it! But I’m too stubborn for ignorance when so many loved ones have been taken. I don’t know how to not speak up for what’s right. I will continue to do so until I can no longer speak.” — Kay 

Stay tuned for the final installment of the series: CRAB Park Warriors: Creating Community Care and Paying Tribute. 

  1. Michael Woodsworth, “The Enduring Power of ‘Poverty Pimps,’” Vital City, March 4, 20205, <https://www.vitalcitynyc.org/the-enduring-power-of-poverty-pimps/>. Poverty-pimp was coined by Pabloe “Yoruba” Guzman, a 19-year-old from East Harlem and a leader of the Young Lords. It is a slang term for people or agencies that make money or gain power from the problems of poor people.  ↩︎
  2. BC Coroner Service, Unregulated Drug Deaths – BC  
    <https://app.powerbi.com/view?r=eyJrIjoiZmY3NTZjZDYtMjZmMy00YmZmLTgyZDAtZDI5ZjIzMmI1OWM1IiwidCI6IjZmZGI1MjAwLTNkMGQtNGE4YS1iMDM2LWQzNjg1ZTM1OWFkYyJ9>.  ↩︎
  3. Alexis Crabtree and Alissa Greer, “What decriminalization in British Columbia could and could not achieve,” Canadian Medical Association Journal, September 14, 2026, Volume 198, Issue 31, E1224, 
    <https://www.cmaj.ca/content/cmaj/198/31/E1224.full.pdf>.  ↩︎

CIVIL LIBERTIES CAN’T PROTECT THEMSELVES